Monday, September 10, 2012

RC#56: Flights of financing


published in Eastern Economist #442, July 23, 2002
Two weeks ago, another promising Ukrainian athlete went missing in action.
            Olena Zubrylova, Ukraine’s top biathlete, declared that she would not extend her contract here. Instead, she would be joining Team Belarus.
            Ukraine has had a long history of losing its talent abroad. World champion jumper Inessa Kravets complained in the mid-nineties about the Olympic Stadium in Kyiv. It was so hard to find a free dumbell, she said, that if you want to train you had to take your trainer piggyback and carry him around.
            Since independence, the disease seems to be spreading as facilities rust and oligarchs spend the country’s assets on themselves and their relatives.
            When a sledder left in the middle of the Salt Lake City Winter Olympics, the reasons were the same: lack of training facilities and resources—and lousy pay.
            Like most divorces, money seemed to be the biggest sore point.
            A one-time World Champion, Ms. Zubrylova is coached by her husband Roman and says she self-finances most of her own training. She put in a very disappointing performance at Salt Lake City. Apparently she was running a fever at the time.
            Ms. Zubrylova’s reasons are understandable: harsh official criticism, miserable pay, the Federation’s tendency to put its efforts into younger athletes. Meanwhile, Belarus has promised for starters to pay her a monthly stipend of US $1,500.
            It wasn’t easy to get a word out sideways from any of the people involved in this headline. Nor was there any damage control on anyone’s part [see RC#55]. The best DerzhKomSport, the State Sports Committee, could come up with was “Well, we have a very promising team of male biathletes.”
            As a PR opportunity, this whole thing was a bust.
            The deputy chair of DerzhKomSport wasn’t taking calls. Nor would the Biathlon Association or the Olympic Committee comment.
            On July 12, two sports officials agreed to answer some questions.
            DerzhKomSport Chair Maria Bulatova said that she “didn’t know anything.” That she first read about Ms. Zubrylova’s decision in the newspapers. Well, “anything” is a bit of a stretch.
            “We talked about this three times and the last time Olena said: ‘OK, I’ll stay but I need some time to think.’ She didn’t say she would leave for Belarus and switch citizenship.”
            How many times does a top athlete need to tell her bosses she’s not happy for them to get the message?
            “Ms. Zubrylova’s not well,” Ms. Bulatova went on, “and we planned a whole rehabilitation program for this summer, somewhere abroad.” The Committee had recommended cutting back Ms. Zubrylova’s training schedule to give her some time to improve her health.
            OK. What about the money angle?
            The president of the Biathlon Federation, Volodymyr Brynzak, said he hadn’t heard any complaints from Ms. Zubrylova and thought the Federation had done “everything possible” for her.
            “We had no conflicts,” said Mr. Brynzak. “She was my personal guest a number times and one of my friends sponsored her for her Gold Medal with US $5,000.”
            Not to be outdone, Ms. Bulatova responded, “Our Committee spent more than a quarter million hryvnia [under US $50,000] to prepare Olena for Salt Lake City. Her salary here was Hr 1,000. At the Dynamo Society, she was paid about Hr 1,600 as a Security Service Major, and the Federation gave her Hr 500.”
            That comes to Hr 3,100 or under US $600. It’s may be well above the official national average, but nowadays secretaries at rich companies make that much in Kyiv. Slim pickin’s for a sports star.
            “People don’t think about the fact that all our money goes towards our training. No professional international coach will even look at you for less than US $5,000 a week,” said Natasha Medvedeva, the sister of tennis star Andriy Medvedev, on a Gravis sports marathon July 13. Ms. Medvedeva is herself a tennis player who was sidelined in 1998 after an injury.
            Mr. Brynzak also challenged Ms. Bulatova on this point. “Your committee hasn’t financed any Federation activities,” he said angrily. “Ms. Zubrylova won the world championship thanks to us. DerzhKomSport owes the Federation about US $32,000.”
            “Officially, the Belarus NOC has not addressed us at all over this,” Ukraine’s National Olympic Committee spokesman Ivan Bondarchuk told uaSport. “These decisions were made without consulting us.”
            Olena Zybrulova herself, in an interview on Studio 1+1, looked on the verge of tears. “Ukraine doesn’t appreciate what it has,” she said. “Other countries try to make their teams stronger by buying ready-made stars.”
            In an AP report from Sydney back in 1999, Belarus President Alyaksandr Lukashenka was quoted as saying, “Just produce results and you’ll be able to provide for yourself for the rest of your life. I’ll buy you anything you neeed, be it apartments, guns, boats, swimming trunks, even undershirts.”
            His offer has not fallen on deaf ears. Last year, Olympic Champion skier Svetlana Nageikina moved to Minsk from Russia, as did biathletes Yelena Khrustaleva and Yevgenia Kutsepalova. All of them performed at Salt Lake City on the Belarus team. Now, says komanda.com, Russian biathlete Vladimir Drachiov, a many-time World Champion and holder of the World Cup, may follow suit.
            “Without money, you can’t get anywhere in tennis or fencing,” says Serhhiy Holubnytskiy, a fencing champion. “That’s a reality. Everything has to be paid for. The problem here is that the government only responds to results. You have to get to the top before they give you anything, and the minute you don’t have the results, they stop supporting you.”
            A DerzhKomSport insider pooh-poohs this. Olena’s just trying to get a little attention, he says. “There’s an Italian handball player and an American swimmer who want to join Ukraine’s team.” We’ll believe that when we see it. •
–from the notebooks of Pan O., with thanks to Yuriy and Bill.

No comments: